Laceys Solicitors Laceys is a leading, forward-thinking law firm with specialist experts serving both individual and business clients across a broad spectrum of practice areas.

If Social Services have notified you about legal proceedings concerning your child please call 01202 377995.



restricted covenant

Restrictive covenants and development sites

14th April 2022 by Mark Preece

Categories: What's New?
Tags: , ,

Even the most promising development can be knocked off course if the land is subject to a restrictive covenant.  Restrictions of this sort can prevent land being built on or being used for specific purposes for many years, even if the development has planning permission.  There are practical ways to work around restrictive covenants if you know about them, so it is a good idea to get advice from your solicitor as early as possible.

‘Restrictive covenants can cause big problems for developers, causing bad feeling and costing money,’ says Mark Preece, head of commercial property with Laceys Solicitors.  ‘There may have been good reasons for a restriction when it was imposed but it will still bind the land even if circumstances have changed, sometimes more than a hundred years later.’ 

What are restrictive covenants?

Restrictive covenants are agreements between landowners preventing a specified use or activity on one piece of land, for the benefit of another.  They are typically imposed when someone sells off part of a larger site and wants to make sure that the part sold will not be used in a way that interferes with their enjoyment of the part they are retaining. 

Examples of typical restrictive covenants include:

  • not building on certain parts of a site;
  • not building more than a specified number of dwellings on a site;
  • not building above a specified height; or
  • not using the land for specific trades or businesses, or in a way that may cause a nuisance to the owners of the land with the benefit of the covenant.

A restrictive covenant may say that development requires the consent of the landowner with the benefit of the covenant.  As time passes, it often becomes difficult to identify who currently has that benefit, especially where land has been subdivided and sold on.

What are the penalties for breaching a restrictive covenant?

It can be tempting to ignore a restrictive covenant and carry on with the development, especially where the covenant was imposed many years ago, but this is very risky.  A developer could be subject to a court injunction requiring the work to stop or may even be ordered to demolish a completed building.  The courts can choose to impose damages, instead of stopping the development, but are likely to impose harsher remedies on developers who have deliberately ignored a restriction without trying to negotiate a release or using the proper statutory process (see below). 

What can you do about a restrictive covenant?

The covenant may no longer be enforceable.  The benefit of covenants imposed before 1926 must be legally ‘annexed’ to land by specific wording in sale documents and if this was not done correctly, there may be no one who can enforce the covenant.  Bath Rugby Club have recently won a legal battle to prove that a restrictive covenant which could have prevented them upgrading their stadium is no longer enforceable.  In that case, the land intended to have the benefit of the covenant could not be clearly identified, so the Court of Appeal decided that the covenant could not be enforced.  The rules on this are complex and depend on when the covenant was entered into, how it was worded, and whether it has been correctly registered, so good legal advice is essential.

If your solicitor concludes that the covenant is enforceable, there are three options for dealing with it.

  • Applying to court – there is a statutory process for getting a covenant altered or removed if the court is satisfied that it is obsolete or it prevents a reasonable use of the land, or that the person with the benefit has agreed or will not be adversely affected. This really depends on the specific situation and your solicitor will advise you about how likely you are to succeed.  Your conduct could make a difference here.  In 2020, the Supreme Court refused to modify a restrictive covenant affecting a development next to a children’s hospice, expressing disapproval of the way the developer had behaved in continuing to build, despite being aware of the covenant. 
  • Negotiation – if you know who has the benefit of the covenant, you may be able to negotiate with them to release it, usually in return for a payment. If the covenant was imposed when part of the adjacent land was sold off, that land may be bound by a matching covenant, in which case you may be able to agree a mutual release.
  • Insurance – depending on the age and wording of the covenant, you can usually get indemnity insurance to cover any costs and losses incurred if you develop the land in breach of the covenant and it is enforced against you. The premium will depend on the insurer’s assessment of how likely it is that someone will try to enforce the covenant.  Bear in mind that insurers will usually refuse to insure if you have already approached the person with the benefit of the covenant so, even if negotiation looks like the obvious first step, you must discuss with your solicitor in advance whether insurance could be a better solution.

How we can help

If you inadvertently build in breach of a restrictive covenant, or if you buy land without knowing that it is subject to restrictions, it could cost you money and may even stop your development plans completely.  Getting good legal advice at the outset will help you assess the risk and decide on the best tactical approach to make sure you do not lose a profitable development opportunity.

If you would like further advice on this subject please contact Mark Preece on 01202 377800 or email

 This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Please note that the law may have changed since this article was published.

Mark Preece

Partner — Commercial and Residential Property

Direct dial: 01202 377862


Mark Preece image profile
  • “Mark and the team take great care of our commercial property requirements. We have always been delighted with their service.”

    Simon Ward, NSN Propertis Ltd

  • “Quick, responsive service. Prepared to recommend a way forward and not sit on the fence.”

    Guy Eccles

  • “Efficient, competent and friendly.”

    Michael Bond

  • “Straightforward. Everything kept clear and simple.”

    Nicola Maidment

  • “I appreciate the personal service and the feeling that my business is important. I also respond well to a friendly approach.”

    Andrew Taylor

  • “Mark noted the requirements of the sale and worked very hard to achieve an excellent prompt outcome. He phoned me immediately the deal was done!”

    Paul R Barry

  • “Excellent service provided by Mark Preece and his team.”

    Francis & Natalia Erard

  • “Everyone at Lacey's seem to have my best interest at heart and act super efficiently. A pleasure to deal with.”

    John Beauchamp

Mark qualified as a solicitor in 2008 after gaining an LLB (2003) and LLM (2005) at university’s in Birmingham.  He completed his training contract with the North Dorset and South Wiltshire firm now known as Farnfields LLP and joined Horsey Lightly Fynn (HLF) in Bournemouth in 2011.  He became a partner at HLF in 2014 and at merger of HLF and Laceys became a partner in the merged firm in 2015.

Mark is a partner working across our Commercial and Residential property teams acting for a wide variety of clients from property developers, property investors, businesses, first time buyers and those needing advice relating to enfranchisement and residential landlord and tenant dealing with all aspects of property work.

Away from work Mark spends his time with his wife and their three young boys who keep them very busy.

Related articles

Commercial property, green space, and The Queen’s Green Canopy

From individual landowners to corporate developers, everyone is being encouraged to play their part in enhancing our...

Read Article

restricted covenant

Restrictive covenants and development sites

Even the most promising development can be knocked off course if the land is subject to a...

Read Article

Close X